Welcome to the DevoreRealtyGroup.com Blog

2017-02-27 13:41:52
Misleading Math Behind the Rent vs Buy Calculation

'The Misleading Math Behind the Rent vs. Buy Calculation' www.realtor.com Author: Jonathan Smoke; Posted on 02/17/2017. Retrieved on 02/27/2017 at http://www.realtor.com/news/trends/misleading-math-rent-vs-buy/?identityID=9620359&MID=2017_0224_WeeklyNL&RID=348938442&cid=eml-2017-0224-WeeklyNL-blog_1_misleadingmathrentvsbuy-blogs_trends 

There’s about $13.1 trillion stashed away in the United States, in plain sight. Where? In our homes!

Do we have your attention yet?

That’s the total value of the equity held by over 75 million U.S. homeowners, according to the latest estimates from the Federal Reserve Board. And that works out to almost $175,000 per owning household.

This is unmistakable evidence that homeownership is a critical building block of household wealth. Owning a home is a key reason why the median net worth of a homeowner is almost $200,000 while the median net worth of a renting household is just over $5,000.

Sure, part of that is because owners were able to pony up a chunk of money to put down on a house, and to qualify for a mortgage. But the act of paying for a mortgage actually helps produce more wealth, by freezing payment amounts and building equity through forced savings.

The traditional rent versus buy argument compares the total monthly costs of buying a home with a mortgage with the corresponding rent. So that comparison is relevant when it comes to representing the housing choice trade-off in clear cost terms. A 30-year amortized, fixed-rate mortgage is a beautiful thing. It provides an affordable path to buying a home while locking in today’s cost of that home for the life of the loan.

Two years ago, that head-to-head heavily favored buying, thanks to very low mortgage rates and lower prices. Back then, more than three-quarters of the counties in the country saw lower buying costs than renting costs.

With prices and rates higher now, less than half of the counties in the country see math that favors buying.

But those raw numbers hide the fact that unlike a rent check, a percentage of every monthly mortgage payment—after the lender is paid interest—goes toward the owner’s home equity. That means it’s really a forced savings plan.

Over time, less of the mortgage payments go toward interest and more go toward equity, so the savings power is enhanced further.

Here’s how that works out for a median-price home of $250,000 bought in January with 20% down with a monthly payment of $976.

Before their first payment, the proud new homeowners had $50,000 in equity thanks to their down payment. (Actually, 20% down isn’t always typical or necessary, but, hey, it keeps this illustration simple.)

In the first year, an average of 29% of the monthly payments builds equity. After 12 payments, the homeowners have just over $3,400 in added equity.

By year 14, 50% of the monthly $976 payment goes toward equity. Don’t forget that the monthly payment hasn’t changed, because the interest rate was fixed.

At the end of the 14th year, just shy of $64,000 has been added to the initial $50,000 in equity.

In the final year of the 30-year mortgage, while the monthly payment remains $976, 98% of the monthly payments builds equity until that magic day when the home is owned free and clear.

Think you can beat that with rents? Researchers at Harvard put it this way:

“While studies simulating the financial returns to owning and renting find that renting is often more likely to be beneficial, in practice renters rarely accumulate any wealth. In no small part this seems traceable to the difficulties households face in trying to save absent either a clear goal or an automatic savings mechanism.”

So, you want a better rent versus buy illustration? First, find a place to rent for no more than $976—the same as our mortgage payment example above. If you can rent for less, great. Will you be able to save that difference amounting to at least $3,400 in the first year? That would imply you can really pay only about $700 in rent to get the same savings effect.

If you can’t save $3,400 yourself by paying less in rent, ask the landlord if he’ll take a portion of your rent payments and set it aside for your rainy day fund.

Then ask the landlord if he’ll set your rent payment at today’s rate for the next 30 years. And before you close the deal, ask him to raise the rainy day share each year by 1% to 2% until year 30, when he’ll get only 2% of the rent payment.

Clearly, this would not be easy to do.

Even if the house only keeps pace with inflation over 30 years, which is a very conservative assumption, the forced savings inherent in a mortgage guarantees a homeowner is building wealth. A renter household has to be extremely diligent to amass the same savings that the good ol’ 30-year mortgage does automatically.

Jonathan Smoke is the chief economist of realtor.com, where he analyzes real estate data and trends to develop market insights for the consumer.

 

 
Blog Archive
2017-04-21 06:42:10
Why are renters staying put?

2017-04-20 06:49:29
Homeowner Value Estimates vs. Appraisals

2017-04-09 07:26:48
San Diego 8th Hottest Real Estate Market

2017-04-03 13:29:11
8 Questions to Ask When Deciding to Rent or Buy

2017-03-31 17:41:05
San Diego rent prices vs. home prices

2017-03-24 13:33:28
Preparing Your Budget for Buying Your First Home

2017-03-24 10:02:40
San Diego home prices dip in February

2017-03-15 17:54:30
County Housing Patterns Shifting

2017-03-03 11:32:47
Where millennials want to live might surprise you

2017-02-27 13:41:52
Misleading Math Behind the Rent vs Buy Calculation

2017-02-24 10:38:59
Older Americans Face Challenges Aging in Place

2017-02-21 15:12:32
Moving Less in U.S.: American Dream Takes a Hit

2017-02-07 13:52:11
Millennials, Housing, and the American Dream

2017-02-01 11:50:46
20 Hottest Markets for U.S. Real Estate in January

2017-01-31 18:13:12
January, February Prime Months to Purchase a Home

2017-01-26 14:47:42
Home Buyer Challenges for 2017

2017-01-19 12:21:59
Nation's Priciest House: $250M

2017-01-13 14:17:03
Are local housing's price gains real?

2017-01-13 12:06:22
Housing Outlook 2017: Eight Predictions

2016-12-30 11:05:38
Trump Win Could Usher in Boom for U.S. Housing

2016-12-19 18:12:11
Is the Starter Home Coming Back?

2016-12-19 17:28:35
Interest rate increased, where will consumers feel

2016-12-19 16:47:51
Step Aside HAMP, There's a New Kid in Town

2016-12-08 17:45:40
Marketwatch Report November 2016

2016-12-08 17:10:21
FHA Loan Limits To Rise in 2017

Click here to see ALL articles.


Comment on this Article

Your Name:
Your Email:
Comments:
Verify:  Please enter the numbers shown to help eliminate spam.