Economists weigh in on the real estate market
Another Southern California home-price boom is cooling. Is a crash looming?
The Southern California housing market has been on a nearly seven-year tear, with prices in many communities reaching all-time highs.
But now, as mortgage rates rise, the boom appears to be fading. Sales are ping; inventory is swelling; more sellers are scaling back their ambitious asking prices.
The annals of postwar Southern California real estate history are full of boom-and-bust cycles, with periods of sharp price appreciation that suddenly skid to a halt. Whether those ups and downs offer any guidance — or hope — for today’s homeowners is a subject for debate.
Some of those who study the housing market predict annual price increases will slow. Others think values could dip. But there is general agreement that a meltdown is not in the offing, given a healthy economy and dearth of home building. The current slowdown, said Christopher Thornberg of Beacon Economics, “is a bump in the road.”
First the good news: There is little reason to believe a bubble anything like the one that popped in 2007 has formed or is forming now.
Last decade, the region was several years into a real estate upswing when prices accelerated. They increased at double-digit rates for six years, fueled by a wave of risky, even predatory, lending. Borrowed money could be used for an entire down payment. Lenders didn’t require proof of income. Low “teaser” rates lured homeowners, but socked them later with huge payments. In some cases, the loan principal that homeowners owed even grew, because their payments didn’t cover interest.
Homeowners soon missed payments and, when the home-equity train slowed, couldn’t refinance either. Defaults rose and the market went into a tailspin. John Burns, a longtime consultant for major home builders, said the housing downturn might have had a “soft landing” if it had remained there. But to stoke the mortgage furnace, bankers had carved up those risky loans and resold them to investors with credit ratings that often hid the potential for default. Risk spread through the financial system, unnoticed by many until it triggered the worst downturn since the Great Depression. Prices across the six-county region ultimately plunged 51%, according to CoreLogic.
This time around, the risk of a crash from overborrowing is minimal, if not nonexistent, experts said. Reforms after the financial crisis dramatically tightened lending standards. Today, even though lending has eased somewhat, borrowers are more likely to be able to afford their loans.
That’s borne out in the data:
“I don’t think we need to worry this time around about a bursting of a credit bubble,” said Stuart Gabriel, director of the Ziman Center for Real Estate at UCLA. “We can cross that factor off the list.”
A more conventional way for Southern California housing booms to end is through an economic recession. That’s what happened 30 years ago.
In the mid- to late 1980s, Southern California home prices had a remarkable run-up. Builders responded by opening vast tracts in the Inland Empire and Antelope Valley.
Concerns over affordability were growing when military cutbacks at the end of the Cold War hammered the region’s sizable aerospace industry. The housing market was already softening before the worst of the cuts. But job losses accelerated and a national recession arrived in the summer of 1990.
Because of its large concentration of aerospace and other military contractors, Southern California suffered more than the rest of the state and the country. By January 1994, L.A. County alone had lost nearly 550,000 jobs and the economy shifted away from manufacturing toward services.
Nationally, the early 1990s recession pushed home prices down slightly, on a year-over-year basis, for 14 months, according to the Case-Shiller index. In Los Angeles and Orange counties, prices fell each month for nearly six years.
“It was really a function of a structural shift in the way our economy operates,” said Jordan Levine, an economist with the California Assn. of Realtors. Today, the local economy is more diverse than in the early 1990s and can better weather a hit to one specific industry, experts said. And despite concerns over the trade war with China and a volatile stock market, economic indicators remain strong. In Los Angeles and Orange counties, unemployment is at 4.6% and 2.8%. In the Inland Empire, the jobless rate stands at 4.1%. Those areas have added a combined 100,000-plus jobs in the last year.
Thornberg of Beacon Economics cited economic strength and a shortage of housing in predicting that prices would keep rising, just at a slower pace.
In the first eight years of the 1980s, for example, developers in California added one new home for every three new residents, according to data from the state Department of Finance. So far this decade, that ratio is one new home for every five new residents.
Prices in L.A. County have grown an average of 11.4% each year since 2012, according to CoreLogic. That has left only 22% of L.A. County households able to afford the median-priced home in the third quarter, according to the California Assn. of Realtors — but that’s better than 9% during the bubble, when mortgage rates were around two percentage points higher. Price appreciation in the first six years of the 2000s averaged out to nearly 28%.
“Homes are not overpriced,” Thornberg said.
A recession would increase the odds of a home-price . Burns, the consultant, predicts low price appreciation next year, but he’s rethinking that forecast because he believes prices have indeed gotten out of whack with incomes. Values could fall slightly even without a recession, he said; if there is one, prices could fall “dramatically.”
A sizable number of economists do expect an economic downturn in 2020, as interest rates rise and stimulus from President Trump’s tax cuts and increased federal spending fade.
That doesn’t have to lead to a housing bust. During the recession of the early ’80s, home-price growth slowed in the state. Prices dipped in only one year, 1984, which was after the recovery began, and the was minor — only 0.1%, according to the California Assn. of Realtors. In L.A. County, other data show prices didn’t fall at all.
Bruce Norris, president of Norris Group, a real estate investment firm in Riverside, said it helped in the 1980s that the state was still attracting more people than it was losing; a decade later, the situation was reversed. He said there were also more foreclosure auctions statewide in the 1990s, which helped sink the market. Today, foreclosures seem less likely, given the tighter lending environment.
But if there’s one lesson from the history of Southern California housing busts, it’s that no one knows exactly when they are coming.
In the late 1980s, experts told the Los Angeles Times that the Southern California economy was probably diverse enough to weather military cuts. “There is no such thing as a slump [in manufacturing] due to the defense budget cuts,” a Wells Fargo economist told The Times in 1989. “I’d call it a pause or a temporary slowdown.”
And in the mid-2000s, while some experts sounded the alarm, others said the market was just slowing down, not crashing. Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke, in testimony before a House committee in February 2006, said: “So we expect the housing market to cool, but not to change very sharply.”
Blog Archive2018-11-13 08:33:28
Economists weigh in on the real estate market
Why waiting to buy can hurt your retirement
The number one reason for mortgage declines
The holidays may decide the fate of the housing market
What will affect home values?
Housing tipping to buyer's market
Why Prop 5 restores fairness to tax system
Is a 'Generational Housing Bubble' Taking Shape?
How high will home prices go?
Are Homes More Affordable Than We Thought?
What home sellers can expect in 2018
Most say tax law will change their plans to buy a home
SD home prices rising at third-highest rate in nation
5 Changes Under the New Tax Law
No Housing Bubble...Yet
San Diego home price increases outpace nation
Homebuyers rush to riskier mortgages
Why It's a Better Time for Buyers on a Budget to Purchase a Home
My newfound purpose
Is it time to sell, San Diego?
The American Dream
Why are renters staying put?
Homeowner Value Estimates vs. Appraisals
San Diego 8th Hottest Real Estate Market
8 Questions to Ask When Deciding to Rent or Buy
San Diego rent prices vs. home prices
Preparing Your Budget for Buying Your First Home
San Diego home prices dip in February
County Housing Patterns Shifting
Where millennials want to live might surprise you
Misleading Math Behind the Rent vs Buy Calculation
Older Americans Face Challenges Aging in Place
Moving Less in U.S.: American Dream Takes a Hit
Millennials, Housing, and the American Dream
20 Hottest Markets for U.S. Real Estate in January
January, February Prime Months to Purchase a Home
Home Buyer Challenges for 2017
Nation's Priciest House: $250M
Are local housing's price gains real?
Housing Outlook 2017: Eight Predictions
Trump Win Could Usher in Boom for U.S. Housing
Is the Starter Home Coming Back?
Interest rate increased, where will consumers feel
Step Aside HAMP, There's a New Kid in Town
Marketwatch Report November 2016
FHA Loan Limits To Rise in 2017
What Trump's Win Means for Southern CA Home Prices
Median Home Price Surpasses $500,000
Autonomous Cars Reshaping Residential Communities
Is Home Equity Still a Retirement Failsafe?
Is the ‘Trump Tantrum’ mortgage rate spike dri
Millennials Aren't Settling In San Diego
Trump victory- great divide among housing experts
What does President Trump mean for the housing mar
76% of Millennials Have Made Housing Compromises
170K More Homes Needed in County By 2025
Who needs location, location, location?
Before you buy that home, avoid utility bill shock
Why millennials are the future of real estate
Surprising amount of first-timers buying homes
Swanky new rental apartment could finally be yours
Student loans & high rent weigh on homeownership
C.A.R. 2017 California Housing Market Forecast
These large metros are seeing the fastest growth
10 ways to evaluate if a home will grow with you
5 reasons home sellers are sitting on the fence
Renovating Homeowners Embrace Smart Technology
Gender disparity in mortgages
9 Home-Buying Myths You Need to Stop Believing
The best time in history to invest in real estate
San Diego home price gains one of biggest in CA
Post-Recession, homeowners vs. renters
America's 20 Hottest Real Estate Markets in August
The Power of Words When Selling a Home
Negative equity rate keeps lowering for SD homes
CA home sales and median price decrease in July
Multigenerational Living is on the Rise
American Dream is alive, but out of reach for many
Quicken Loans: Homeowners overestimate home values
Make Your Home More Appealing to Young Buyers
San Diego County median home price up by 6.4%
San Diego County home price reaches $495,000
Forecast Projects Increase of 5.3% by May 2017
Millions of Baby Boomers Prefer to Rent
Would you pay $800,000 for a container house?
San Diego's Real Estate Ranking June 2016
Presidential elections & CA's housing market
Student loan debt is hurting the housing market
Are Millenials engaged in the American dream?
Will the Fed Liftoff Be Delayed?
Foreclosure rates decreasing in US, California, an
Resale home prices keep climing in SD, elsewhere
San Diego Foreclosure News
Bryan & Allison's Real Estate Report - 2/28/14
Bryan & Allison's Real Estate Report - 2/17/14
Bryan & Allison's Real Estate Report - 2/2/14
Bryan & Allison's Real Estate Report - 1/24/14
Bryan & Allison's Real Estate Report - 12/31/13
Bryan & Allison's Real Estate Report - 12/15/13
Bryan & Allison's Real Estate Report - 12/3/13
Bryan & Allison's Real Estate Report - 11/21/13
Bryan & Allison's Real Estate Report - 11/12/13
As heard on ESPN Radio AM1700 today!
Bryan & Allison's Real Estate Report - 10/10/13
Bryan & Allison's Real Estate Report - 9/23/13
Bryan & Allison's Real Estate Report - 9/2/13
Real Estate Report for 8/18/13
Real Estate Report for 8/4/13
Real Estate Report for 7/27/13
Real Estate Report for 7/18/13
Real Estate Report for 7/1/13
Real Estate Report for 6/12/13
Real Estate Report for 5/30/13
Real Estate Report for 5/21/13
Weekly Real Estate Report for 5/7/13
Weekly Real Estate Report for 4/29/13
Weekly Real Estate Report for 4/20/13
Bryan & Allison Devore Recognized as Top Producing
Get informed with these great articles
Who to believe?
The latest in real estate...quick and easy!
A New Year - But What About The Old One?
Real Estate Year In Review
Bryan & Allison's Real Estate Tuesday Talk
Prices and foreclosures...good news!
Housing prices continue to rise, but...
This week in real estate
Some interesting news for a Wednesday
Low inventory affecting state and nation
What will the market look like next year?
The real estate recovery is for real this time
Foreclosure numbers continue their decline
CoreLogic Report Shows Prices Continue Increasing
Reports on Home Prices
Finally...the media is paying attention!
More positive news in the world of real estate
Fast start to the week in the world of real estate
This week in real estate
Are appraisals coming in too low?
So there you have it!
Foreclosures in San Diego County are mixed
Home sales up - and down
If you are renting, should you buy?
The debate on principal reduction livens
Prepping for the summer wave of short sales
More evidence that foreclosures are down
What are you paying for your housing?
Fewer homes for more competing buyers
S&P/Case-Shiller Index shows prices increasing
Take 1 minute to get caught up!
A first in 5 years!
More good news for the foreclosure market
It's easy being green...but is it profitable?
Obama Administration releases Housing Scorecard
Do you have a home equity line?
The sad truth about the foreclosure crisis
Home prices in So. Cal. - more good news
This month's HomeDex Report
This month's TrendGraphix report for Carlsbad
Prices up, sales up BIG
Foreclosure numbers down BIG
Another good reason to buy
Another sign of an improving real estate market -
Finally...real help for underwater homeowners
This month's HomeDex Report
More great news about the real estate market
Why the housing recovery is taking longer than it
Further insight into the low housing inventory
Win a $20,000 home makeover!
Is the market bottoming out? Let's ask!
Obama Administration releases May Housing Scorecar
Fighting lowball appraisals
Foreclosure numbers showing continuing stabilizati
Will short sale help be coming to an end?
Foreclosed homeowners finding their way back to ho
Sales of Foreclosure Homes Up in the Nation and St
Mortgage delinquencies continue their decline
Improving your credit score
Even Time Magazine says now is the time to buy
Home affordability at an all time high
Stay Updated On The World of Real Estate
Didn't get the modification you wanted? Now there
Obama Administration Changes Refinancing Plan For
Where should home builders be building?